Ideal Protein Overview
Wow, nice job Carolyn! This was my last resort. Plus, they show you the exact system to follow to reach your weight loss goals — follow the plan they send, and you will lose weight. Leave this field empty. Hi Shirley — What an inspirational story — really hoping she has success!
In order to sign up, I would have needed to call and make an appointment to come in to the clinic and have a consultation—which I expect would have been a hard sell. I did not do that. But I nonetheless wanted to know exactly what this diet is and how much it cost, so I searched until I found a clinic website that included price.
You take a multivitamin, calcium-magnesium supplement, a potassium citrate supplement, an omega-3 supplement, amino acids powder, and Ideal salt. But we do learn that the meal replacements are not optional. During the first phase you will be eating three of the Ideal Protein foods and your own dinner—which is just 8 ounces of lean protein and vegetables. And you stay in this phase until you have lost your weight. Imagine someone needing to lose a hundred pounds or more?
I always read the disclaimer on a weight loss website. You learn a lot: You must use their meal replacements during the first phase—which could last a few months, or a year or more. I did find nutrition labels for some meal replacement foods, like the Triple Chocolate Wafers. But it has, wow, 16 grams of protein. So does three-quarters of a cup of cottage cheese, at calories and 7. With a visible ingredients list.
I located a lot more labels, but none included the actual ingredients; just nutrition info. This one from a center in Groton, Connecticut. This diet—or, actually, complete lifestyle change—purports to be medically sound and created in response to the obesity epidemic. When the American Medical Association AMA recognized obesity as a disease, more and more of these medically-created or supervised kinds of diets and clinics began popping up everywhere. In this case, the clinics, practices, or pharmacies already exist, and they sign on to add Ideal Protein program as an adjunct making money for all.
But science and nutritional experts generally agree that some meal replacements may be okay. And in general, experts say high-protein diets like Ideal Protein are okay for already healthy people. The Mayo Clinic says while diets like this may help with weight loss, the jury is still out on the long-term safety of high-protein-low-carb-low-fat diets because of health concerns. And side effects including headache and constipation. Plus, they say, high-protein diets may hurt people with kidney disease.
Their suggestion is to cut out bad carbs—processed ones—and replace them with whole grains and good carb-rich vegetables. They also say that a restrictive diet is not sustainable: The best eating plan is one that you can stick to long-term.
What about Ideal Protein reviews? Testimonials posted on this website have been provided by individual dieters and are representative of their own personal experience and are not typical. Any statements or claims, posted on this page, are not being made by the owner of this website or by Ideal Protein.
The most recent post about Ideal Protein I found was a message board thread from late My doctor has strong opinions on Ideal Protein she said absolutely not but some doctors say it can be done safely. Ideal Protein is offered at my hospital and many people have joined it and lost dramatic amounts of weight. Almost every person has gained it all back.
The only person I know who lost weight on Ideal Protein and kept it off is a man who married a dietician right after he went off the diet. One full review on Pissed Consumer. But they needed to lose weight and decided to go for it. I started to lose some weight but was constantly sick and had no energy. Then I noticed I was losing my hair. I went to my doctor and was told that this Ideal Protein diet plan was dangerous and that it starves the body of much needed carbs and nutrients.
The main problem with such plans is in the theory itself — the idea that by starving your body of carbohydrates that you will then use fatty tissue for energy, and lose weight. Yes, you will lose weight, but it is not the way that you should want to lose it, and therein lies the problem. The issue is that not only does the fatty tissue get used, but so does the lean tissue.
You know…your heart, liver, kidneys! So, while you are losing weight temporarily you are not losing it properly and can be putting yourself at risk. In addition, you are not giving your body what it needs — your body need carbs to survive, and is very dependent on them. Without them your body will start using what are called ketone bodies instead, which can lead to additional problems due to the imbalances this creates by making your blood overly acidic. Unfortunately, the Ideal Protein Diet falls right into this category, and thus really should be avoided.
She says a lot about Ideal Protein and her experience with it. Also, since the low carb diet sends you into ketosis, you will have bad breath. Based on our research people frequently try to compare Ideal Protein to other weight loss solutions.
Often the brands and their products are different in many ways which makes it hard to compare apples-to-oranges. This is our attempt to compare below 6 and pick the winner. Please take this information with the grain of salt and do your own research. If making dietary changes we recommend consulting with your medical doctor.
I first did Atkins before people got hip and realized that all the garbage and I mean super-bad-for-you junk in processed meats was a really bad idea.
Back in the day, you ate hot dogs and bacon by the pound. I lost a lot of weight doing Atkins because I cut carbs way way way back. Years later, I found that a modified Atkins, a smart really-low bad carb diet was doable.
What you need to know about Ideal Protein is you must be willing to go to a brick-and-mortar center. It is similar to Atkins in theory because its a low-carb, high-protein ketogenic program but with meal replacements and supplements taken after going to a center, then doing the rest of it online and you pay a lot of money for the foods and supplements.
Once on the diet, and after you reach your goal weight presuming you do , you must maintain that loss for a year, meaning you still pay them and still take supplements. Next, lose all the weight you need to lose on their plan, become the new you and stay that way for life.
Do I sound as if I am being a tad facetious? But when we talk about comparing Ideal Protein versus Keto OS know that they have the same ketogenic idea of weight loss so in that way, Keto OS and Ideal Protein are similar, but that's about as far as it goes. I suppose chugging down ketones in their flavored drinks is cheaper, but not by too much, than Ideal Protein. Plus, you don't have to go to a center, purchase foods and supplements, then be monitored online, and later stay on that diet far beyond reaching goal weight if that ever happens.
You need to know that Ideal Shape has a secret ingredient called Slendesta, a so-called hunger blocker, in its meal replacement shakes within its proprietary blend of protein and fiber that they say works because you feel full longer than with regular meal replacement shakes.
If you prefer, you can accept the default menu that Nutrisystem suggests when you sign up for the program. Medifast and Nutrisystem require you to purchase other foods in addition to the diet products.
The Medifast Lean and Green Meal includes 6 to 8 ounces of lean protein, vegetables and up to two servings of healthy fats. You can also have two small servings of low-calorie condiments each day.
On Nutrisystem, you eat healthy foods from the grocery store to supplement your Nutrisystem meals and snacks. You can have fruits, vegetables, healthy carbohydrates, reduced fat dairy and lean protein. Both Medifast and Nutrisystem offer options for men, women, people with diabetes, older adults and vegetarians. If you do not have as much weight to lose, Nutrisystem might be a better choice because it offers a slower rate of weight loss that agrees with recommendations in the Dietary Guidelines from the U.
Department of Health and Human Services. Video of the Day. Meal Plans Similar to Nutrisystem. Can I Drink Coffee on Medifast? What Is the Cost of Medifast?